Australasian Dental Practice

Sunday, 14 July, 2024

31 Jul 2019 | Australasian Dental Practice

news > Spectrum > Page 40

Carestream Dental CS 3600 intraoral scanner tested to have highest accuracy in latest implantology study

When it comes to placing implants, accuracy matters and the CS 3600 intraoral scanner was found to give the most accurate results during a new study, Trueness and Precision of Five Intraoral Scanners in the Impressions of Single and Multiple Implants: A Comparative In-Vitro Study.1


With few peer-reviewed studies evaluating the clinical efficacy of intraoral scanners in implantology, these latest findings from Drs Francesco Guido Mangano, Uli Hauschild, Giovanni Veronesi, Mario Imburgia, Carlo Mangano and Oleg Admakin compared the trueness and precision of five intraoral scanners and determined which have both accurate and consistent results.

According to the study, the CS 3600 had the best accuracy, while having the fewest "triangles" making up the meshes in all applications.

"The number of triangles is often misinterpreted to be a measure of acquisition resolution or mesh quality," Victor Wong, PhD, director, research and innovation, Carestream Dental, said. "In fact, by having the best trueness with the smallest number of triangles, the CS 3600 demonstrates the most efficient/optimal mesh generation by placing more triangles in areas with more details and vice versa, with minimised mesh file size while maintaining accuracy."

To put the scanners to the test, 10 scans were performed by a single digital dentistry expert per indication per intraoral scanner with a zig-zag technique in the same environmental conditions. Two maxilla plaster models were used as a reference: One partially edentulous and one fully edentulous.

In this study, trueness is defined by the difference between the scanned model and the reference model; precision is quantified by the difference between repeatedly scanned models. In both cases, smaller values indicate greater trueness and/or precision. A scanner needs both trueness and precision to be considered accurate.

When scanning a single crown, the CS 3600 was found to have the best trueness (15.2 ±0.8 μm) and the best precision (11.3 ±1.1 μm). The CS 3600 also had the best trueness (23 ±1.1 μm) and the best precision (21 ±1.9 μm) when scanning a partial prosthesis. While scanning a full arch, the CS 3600 had the best trueness (44.9 ±8.9 μm) and had the second-best precision (35.7 ± 4.3), which very closely follows the best precision result (35.6 ± 3.4).

This is not the first time that studies have confirmed the CS 3600's high performance. In a 2018 study,2 the CS 3600 outperformed other scanners, as well as traditional impressions in finish line accuracy. Its trueness was confirmed by a 2017 study that tested the accuracy of four intraoral scanners in oral implantology.3

References

  1. Mangano F, Logozzo S, Hauschild U, Veronesi G, Imburgia M, Mangano C, Admakin O. June 6, 2019. Trueness and precision of 5 intraoral scanners in the impressions of single and multiple implants: a comparative in vitro study. BMC Oral Health. 19(101): DOI 10.1186/s12903-019-0792-7.
  2. Nedelcu R, Nystrom I, Olsson P, Thor A. Feb. 26, 2018. Finish Line Distinctness and Accuracy in 7 Intraoral Scanners versus Conventional Impression: An In-vitro Descriptive Comparison. BMC Oral Health.18(27): DOI 10.1186/s12903-018-0489-3.
  3. Imburgia M, Logozzo S, Hauschild U, Veronesi G, Mangano G, Mangano FG. June 2, 2017. Accuracy of Four Intraoral Scanners in Oral Implantology: A Comparative In-Vitro Study. BMC Oral Health. 17(92): DOI 10.1186/s12903-017-0383-4
Stream the latest dental videos...
VITA Easyshade V: Activation and calibration

Upcoming Events...

Jul 25 2024
Aug 07 2024
Aug 20 2024
Aug 21 2024
Aug 23 2024
Aug 28 2024
Aug 29 2024

Practical Endodontics Workshop

Sydney, AUSTRALIA

Sep 04 2024
Sep 07 2024
Sep 11 2024
Sep 14 2024
Sep 26 2024
Oct 02 2024
Oct 03 2024
Oct 10 2024
Oct 17 2024

ADOHTA 2024 National Congress

Sydney, AUSTRALIA

Oct 24 2024
Nov 06 2024
Nov 07 2024

Veneers: A Comprehensive Guide

Auckland, NEW ZEALAND

Nov 13 2024
Nov 29 2024
Dec 04 2024
Mar 25 2025

IDS 2025

Cologne, GERMANY

May 08 2025
May 30 2025
Mar 20 2026
Apr 17 2026

IDEM Singapore 2026

Singapore, SINGAPORE